Re: [Proposal] Deprecation of the firehose endpoint

Johannes Tuchscherer
 

Hi Neil,

Thanks for the feedback. We actually created PRs for both, firehose-exporter[0] and to firehose-to-syslog[1]. We will continue working with the maintainers to get these pulled in. 

Best,
Johannes


On Tue, Mar 5, 2019 at 11:26 AM Neil MacDougall <neil.macdougall@...> wrote:
Johannes,

A 6 month deprecation window works for Stratos - that should be fine for us to update.

If you can work with the firehose-exporter project to get that updated and off the firehose within the next 2 or 3 months, that would be super helpful and give us time to integrate and test, assuming its a drop-in replacement for the current firehose based version.

Many thanks,

Neil

On 25 Feb 2019, at 23:51, Johannes Tuchscherer <jtuchscherer@...> wrote:

Hi everybody,

thanks for the continuous stream of feedback. We are definitely going to support the firehose-exporter and firehose-to-syslog projects off the firehose to the RLP. The stories in our backlog are coming up soon. Stanislav, do you think that looking at what we did with the firehose-to-syslog project would help you to migrate the kafka-firehose-nozzle?

Also, based on the feedback I have received so far I am open to increasing the deprecation window to 6 months. Would that be acceptable?

Thanks,
Johannes

On Sun, Feb 24, 2019 at 4:22 PM Stanislav German-Evtushenko <s.germanevtushenko@...> wrote:
Hi Johannes,

We are heavy users of loggregator and we have the same concerns as others in the thread.

We use loggregator for:
- storing all application logs for 6 month (regulations requirement) using kafka-firehose-nozzle
- getting all platform metrics for monitoring purposes using kafka-firehose-nozzle
- getting all applications metrics to provide monitoring dashboard using kafka-firehose-nozzle and cf-metrics-refinery (see https://cloudfoundry.slack.com/messages/C6WFZ5K0F/p1531268612000101)

Another concern is autoscaler (https://github.com/cloudfoundry-incubator/app-autoscaler-release). It is relying on loggregator and I haven't seen any updates on moving out of it yet.

Best regards,
Stanislav



Join cf-dev@lists.cloudfoundry.org to automatically receive all group messages.